The catalytic properties of metallophthalocyanine (MPc) complexes have long been applied to electrochemical sensing of nitric oxide (NO) to amplify sensitivity and reduce the substantial overpotential required for NO oxidation. The latter point has significant ramifications for in situ amperometric detection, as large working potentials oxidize biological interferents (e.g., nitrite, l-ascorbate, and carbon monoxide). Herein, we sought to isolate and quantify, for the first time, the selectivity benefits of MPc modification of glassy carbon electrodes. A series of the most catalytically active MPc complexes towards NO, including Fe(II)Pc, Co(II)Pc, Ni(II)Pc, and Zn(II)Pc, was selected and probed for NO sensing ability under both differential pulse voltammetry (DPV) and constant potential amperometry (CPA). Data from DPV measurements provided information with respect to MPc signal sensitivity amplification (∼1.5×) and peak shifting (100–200 mV). Iron-Pc exerted the most specific catalytic activity towards NO over nitrite. Catalyst-enabled reduction of the working potential under CPA was found to improve selectivity for NO over high potential interferents, regardless of MPc. However, impaired selectivity against low potential interferents was also noted.