Antiquity ( IF 1.9 ) Pub Date : 2024-09-12 , DOI: 10.15184/aqy.2024.88 Rasmus G. Bjørn
The reviewed volumes represent the past and future of triangulating human prehistory. Both works address the integration of the knowledge embedded in the Indo-European group of languages into the interpretation of archaeological and genetic data, but approach this very differently. By enlisting the expertise of scholars from the three different fields, with 22 contributions from more than 40 scholars from more than 10 different countries, The Indo-European puzzle revisited is both a seminal work and a resounding commentary on the, by its very nature, limited perspectives voiced by Jean-Paul Demoule as a sole archaeologist author of his book The Indo-Europeans. The title of the former is based on the subtitle of Colin Renfrew's Archaeology and language: the puzzle of Indo-European origins (1987), another archaeologist's foray into historical linguistics.
中文翻译:
二十一世纪印欧家园之光:三角测量语言、考古学和遗传学
所审查的卷代表了三角测量人类史前史的过去和未来。这两部作品都致力于将印欧语系中嵌入的知识整合到考古和遗传数据的解释中,但处理方法却截然不同。通过征集来自三个不同领域的学者的专业知识,以及来自 10 多个不同国家的 40 多名学者的 22 份贡献, 《重温印欧谜题》既是一部开创性的著作,也是对本质上的一个响亮的评论。让-保罗·德穆勒(Jean-Paul Demoule)作为《印欧人》一书的唯一考古学家作者,表达了有限的观点。前者的标题取自科林·伦弗鲁(Colin Renfrew)的《考古学与语言:印欧起源之谜》 (1987)的副标题,这是另一位考古学家涉足历史语言学的著作。