This commentary engages the articles in the “Citizenship, Solidarity, and Nonbelonging” forum by discussing three points: citizen participation in and challenges to bureaucratic practices; the spatialities of citizenship and belonging; and the potentials for co‐optation of civic mobilization vis‐à‐vis the privatization of state responsibilities. It concludes that citizen mobilizations can effectively structure the terms of the debate and create new forms of belonging in the wake of inherited injustices.

中文翻译：

---

公民身份的空间和挑战


这篇评论结合了“公民权、团结和非归属感”论坛上的文章，讨论了三点：公民对官僚实践的参与和挑战；公民身份和归属感的空间性；以及公民动员相对于国家责任私有化的潜力。它的结论是，公民动员可以有效地构建辩论的条款，并在继承的不公正之后创造新的归属形式。