当前位置:
X-MOL 学术
›
Q. J. Econ.
›
论文详情
Our official English website, www.x-mol.net, welcomes your
feedback! (Note: you will need to create a separate account there.)
Stories, Statistics, and Memory
The Quarterly Journal of Economics ( IF 11.1 ) Pub Date : 2024-06-10 , DOI: 10.1093/qje/qjae020 Thomas Graeber 1 , Christopher Roth 2 , Florian Zimmermann 3
The Quarterly Journal of Economics ( IF 11.1 ) Pub Date : 2024-06-10 , DOI: 10.1093/qje/qjae020 Thomas Graeber 1 , Christopher Roth 2 , Florian Zimmermann 3
Affiliation
For many decisions, we encounter relevant information over the course of days, months or years. We consume such information in various forms, including stories – qualitative content about individual instances – and statistics – quantitative data about collections of observations. This paper proposes that information type – story versus statistic – shapes selective memory. In controlled experiments, we document a pronounced story-statistic gap in memory: the average impact of statistics on beliefs fades by 73% over the course of a day, but the impact of a story fades by only 32%. Guided by a model of selective memory, we disentangle different mechanisms and document that similarity relationships drive this gap. Recall of a story increases when its qualitative content is more similar to a memory prompt. Irrelevant information in memory that is similar to the prompt, on the other hand, competes for retrieval with relevant information, impeding successful recall.
中文翻译:
故事、统计数据和记忆
对于许多决策,我们会在几天、几个月或几年的过程中遇到相关信息。我们以各种形式消费此类信息,包括故事(有关个体实例的定性内容)和统计数据(有关观察集合的定量数据)。本文提出信息类型——故事与统计——塑造选择性记忆。在对照实验中,我们记录了记忆中明显的故事统计差距:统计数据对信念的平均影响在一天内减弱了 73%,但故事的影响仅减弱了 32%。在选择性记忆模型的指导下,我们理清了不同的机制,并记录了相似性关系推动了这一差距。当故事的定性内容更类似于记忆提示时,对故事的回忆就会增加。另一方面,记忆中与提示相似的不相关信息会与相关信息竞争检索,从而阻碍成功回忆。
更新日期:2024-06-10
中文翻译:
故事、统计数据和记忆
对于许多决策,我们会在几天、几个月或几年的过程中遇到相关信息。我们以各种形式消费此类信息,包括故事(有关个体实例的定性内容)和统计数据(有关观察集合的定量数据)。本文提出信息类型——故事与统计——塑造选择性记忆。在对照实验中,我们记录了记忆中明显的故事统计差距:统计数据对信念的平均影响在一天内减弱了 73%,但故事的影响仅减弱了 32%。在选择性记忆模型的指导下,我们理清了不同的机制,并记录了相似性关系推动了这一差距。当故事的定性内容更类似于记忆提示时,对故事的回忆就会增加。另一方面,记忆中与提示相似的不相关信息会与相关信息竞争检索,从而阻碍成功回忆。