The majority of tissue-specific environmental quality standards (EQSs) considering metal tolerance are prior to the chemical-specific EQSs in aquatic organisms. However, metal baseline levels in marine organisms were very scarce. We explored the correlation between Hg, Cd, Pb, Cu, and Zn concentrations in water or sediments and those metal concentrations in marine organisms (crustacean, mollusc, and fish) by generalized additive models (GAMs) and executed a meta-analysis of Hg, Cd, Pb, Cu, and Zn contents in those three organisms by implementing cumulative frequency distribution analysis of individual metal distribution in a heavy metal-contaminated semi-enclosed Bay, China. Results showed that the average contents of Hg, Cd, Pb, Cu, and Zn were 0.042±0.01, 0.38±0.22, 1.72±0.65, 3.61±1.01, and 16.08±6.33 μg/L in water; 0.064±0.02, 0.42±0.04, 20.54±7.76, 28.97±3.90, and 96.74±35.11 μg/g dw in sediment; and 0.0049±0.0028, 0.52±0.28, 0.24±0.15, 11.05±6.95, and 21.12±4.47 μg/g dw in crustacean, 0.015±0.0087, 0.24±0.17, 0.08±0.02, 0.37±0.35, and 10.62±6.79 μg/g dw in mollusc; and 0.0038±0.0028, 0.065±0.05, 0.32±0.19, 2.01±0.59, and 16.04±4.97 μg/g dw in fish. The mercury content in mollusc presented a negative correlation with mercury content in sediment, while the content of other metals (Cd, Pb, Cu, and Zn) in organisms showed positive correlations with the content of those metals in water or sediment. We further obtained tissue-baseline-C5% in crustacean, mollusc, and fish which were 1.191, 3.341, and 0.014 μg/g dw for Cu; 0.013, 0.072, and 0.033 μg/g dw for Cd, 0.015, 0.027, and 0.052 μg/g dw for Pb; 9.515, 14.422, and 0.056 μg/g dw for Zn; and 0.0009, 0.004, and 0.0035 μg/g dw for Hg, respectively. However, there were no obvious relationships of the 4d-NOEC in laboratory toxicity tests with C5%, as well as C50% and 4d-LC50 or tolerance index a for Cu, Cd, Pb, Zn, and Hg in organisms. Our results pointed out the controversy of laboratory sensitive species toxicity results for deriving chemical-specific EQSs with field studies. We advocated to set up the metal concentration baselines in aquatic organisms and further served the tissue-specific EQSs, which are essential basis for geochemical recordings, bio-monitoring, and semi-enclosed bay management in the world.

Graphical abstract